
I heard from a couple pastor friends of mine recently who are of the opinion that Concordia Publishing House should release Luther’s Small Catechism into the public domain so anyone, anywhere, can do whatever they want to do with it. I understand the sentiment and have no doubt that their interest in having this happen is well intended, but, unfortunately, there are a number of assumptions behind this opinion that are based on misinformation, or simply erroneous assumptions. Here is information I shared with the pastors, that you might find useful too.
Did you know that Concordia Publishing House grants permission for a wide range of use of the SC text in the parish and classroom and for personal use? Please see this copyright notice contained on our web site. Note that “reproduction in whole or in part for noncommercial personal, congregational, or classroom use” is permitted! What’s not permitted is copying and pasting the text all over the Internet, or producing resources for distribution beyond the parish one is called to serve. But that’s no biggie, since we provide the entire Small Catechism text online, which is easily linked to from any blog site, forum or web site. Here it is, so link away. And here’s that copyright notice:
Copyright notice:
From Luther’s Small Catechism © 1986 Concordia Publishing House. All rights reserved. Other than reproduction in whole or in part for noncommercial personal, congregational, or classroom use, no part of this material may be reproduced or stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of Concordia Publishing House. Concordia invites you to place links to this site on your Web site and other social networks. To obtain permission for other uses, please contact Concordia Publishing House at 800-325-0191 or e-mail us at copyrights@cph.org.
Let’s consider some other factors.
The LCMS entrusts to CPH the management of its published intellectual property and we hold many resources in trust for the Synod, such as the SC. Such materials are carefully managed by CPH and kept safe from misuse, which is all the more prevalent in today’s Internet world. We have the financial ability to publish these materials on a larger scale than any “do it yourself” operations out there. We disseminate literally hundreds of thousands of copies of the SC every single year in a vast variety of formats. This is work that nobody else can do because of the resource requirements that must be brought to bear to keep this all going.
Some like to speculate that CPH can just “make money elsewhere.” This kind of assumption is simply incorrect. It is precisely because we do recover our costs and make a bit more on resources that are core product lines: like the curriculum that we are able to keep publishing things that we make NO return on, in fact, we routinely publish at a “loss” resources like: The Treasury of Daily Prayer, Luther’s Works, Gerhard’s volumes, and all the digital resources you are enjoying. The *only* way we are able to afford to do these resources, AND, hold down prices elsewhere is because we do sell the SC and various curriculum pieces containing it. Without this revenue, we simply could not continue to do everything we do. We must see a return on our investment of resources somewhere, and we realize it through sale of our core resources: all curriculum pieces, bulletins, offering envelopes. Any funds we receive in excess of our expenses is reinvested in future resources. Nobody funds CPH. The Synod does not, grants do not, we are self-sustaining and have been since the Synod gave CPH $30,000 for printing press equipment back around 1869!
So, if folks want CPH to release the text of the most current translation of the SC into the public domain they can expect: prices on all our resources to go up, and for us to shut down publishing the very books and resources they say they love. It’s just that simple folks. You can’t have it both ways.
I need simply to ask that we take up again the appreciation The LCMS has always had, and extend support for, the existence of a publishing house devoted to publishing resources faithful to the Scriptures and the Lutheran Confessions. If we no longer value the existence of such a publishing house and truly believe that individuals, atomistically acting as they see fit, can do more and do it better than can an entire publishing operation devoted to this and many other publishing resources, then The LCMS should simply shut down CPH, and wish everyone well and effectively say, “Good luck! Hope it all turns out!”
I do not say this as a boast or brag, but simply as a statement of fact. There is no other publishing company in the world today, that has our internal capacity, size and resources, able to publish confessionally Lutheran materials on the scale and to the extent that Concordia Publishing House does. People gush on to me all the time about how much they love The Lutheran Study Bible, or the Treasury of Daily Prayer, or the Lutheran Service Book, or the Concordia Commentary series, or the Spirituality of the Cross, or our Bible studies, or our Sunday School curriculum, or VBS, you name it. But it is, well, more than a little frustrating when some of these very same people turn right around and start demanding we simply give away core, current intellectual property for free. One is nearly at a loss for words when that happens, well, I guess this post proves I’m never at a loss for words on these points.
But I’m of the strong opinion that there is still incredible value in, and opportunity for, a publishing company that has the resources we do and I think it is worthy of being supported vigorously. This means that we continue to allow CPH to manage the copyrights for The LCMS, as we always have, and to be and remain the publisher for The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod.

And finally . . and thanks for reading this far . . . we are launching a new resource that offers a comprehensive web-based confirmation curriculum support tool, offering online quizzing of your students, and interactive and ongoing monitoring of your quizzing, etc. along with a range of resources, to which we will be adding more in the coming months. Included in all this is the entire SC text, along with PowerPoints designed specifically to teach the six chief parts. It is available via subscription based on average Sunday morning worship attendance. Check it out at:
http://www.confirmationbuilder.com
I am asking for your support and understanding. Thanks!
Recent Comments